Custom GC helps researchers tackle the energy crisis
Shimadzu’s custom gas systems enable research into alternative energy sources
Dr. Anna Cooper, Shimadzu UK
Despite the versatility of the gas chromatography (GC) systems and columns available off-the-shelf, the GC analysis of permanent gases remains a specialist field requiring a more bespoke approach. We talk to Peter Klawitter, who for nearly 20 years has been the in-house expert on these custom GC instruments at Shimadzu UK. As well as hearing from him what’s involved in designing these systems, we discover why these bespoke GC systems are proving so useful and popular in the rapidly growing research field of “new energy”.
Hello Peter! Can you start by describing what you do in the custom GC group at Shimadzu? Thanks for the opportunity to talk! In our group, we devise, build and sell bespoke gas chromatography (GC) systems to the UK market. These are mostly for analysis of commonly encountered permanent gases such as hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, methane, carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide, but we also deal with some of the more obscure gases such as ammonia and nitrous oxide.
We’ve grown substantially since I started at Shimadzu in 2003, and we’ve now got about 70 systems installed in the UK. Many of these are in university labs – and that’s actually where much of our current focus lies in terms of new systems.
Why are custom GC systems needed? Isn’t it possible to devise a “one-size-fits-all” solution for gas analysis? That’s a fair point. Unlike the VOCs (volatile organic compounds) and SVOCs (semivolatile organic compounds) analysed by standard GC systems, permanent gases have a much greater variety of physical and chemical characteristics – what we call ‘chemistries’. These really complicate separation and detection and limit the types of columns we can use.
So, for example, CO2 poisons the commonly used molecular sieve columns, while FID (flame ionization detector) detection won’t work for anything without a hydrocarbon bond.
Ammonia is a tricky one as well as it’s pretty aggressive and so needs to be split off into its own detection and analysis line. And in the most challenging situations involving sulfur species, we have to refit the internals of the GC with specially treated alloys to stop the samples ‘sticking’ to the components!
As a result of all this, you typically need multiple columns and detectors for gas analysis as well as valving to separate out the target species, and carefully considered valve flows and timings to ensure optimum performance.
Essentially, this means that each time a customer comes to us with an application request, we need to create a customized GC system for them. The ‘chemistries’ just don’t allow a ‘one-size-fits-all’ solution.
Apart from analyte chemistry, what other considerations are there in designing a new system? A major factor is the analyte level we’re looking at. So, if the customer just wants to detect at levels of say 0.1% and above, then a thermal conductivity detector (TCD) is usually fine. But even then, we might have to think about the carrier gas because TCDs can’t distinguish between hydrogen and helium. And, of course, we need to consider whether the detector might be overloaded by high-abundance compounds and so require the flow to be split. On the other hand, when the customer needs low detection limits, which is happening quite a lot now especially with our customers in academia, we’ll need a more sensitive detector.
But ultimately, we make our system designs as simple as we can and deal with the necessary complexity as far as possible through the method. That way, our customers get the best system robustness, performance and flexibility.
When you build the custom GCs, do you start from a standard GC system? Yes, the core frame for the majority of our builds is the Shimadzu Nexis GC-2030. Its design allows all our additional valving to be fitted on top of the instrument. This frees up the left-hand side of the GC for coupling to an MS (mass spectrometry) detector, which is very handy for applications involving isotope work.
And as for detection, I’ve already mentioned TCD, but there’s also FID for hydrocarbons and ECD (electron capture detector) for nitrous oxide. Plus, we have our own patented barrier ionization detector or BID – released back in 2014 – which offers much lower detection limits for the permanent gases.
Figure 2: Close-up of the custom GC valving and flowpaths in place on top of the GC. An MS detector can be added, if needed.
That sounds like a really useful development for custom GC. How does it work? Yes, it’s been a game-changer for us really. At the heart of the BID is a quartz dielectric chamber, which generates a helium plasma that ionizes pretty much everything that elutes from the GC. What makes the BID different from previous helium ionization detectors is that the electrodes have a dielectric coating, preventing the plasma from eating away at them and giving the detector much higher precision and excellent long-term stability.
But the main benefit for the analyst is the lower detection limits: the BID is 100 to 200 times as sensitive as TCD! When specifying systems for customers, I usually quote down to about 30 ppm for most of the permanent gases, but you can fairly easily get lower than that by optimizing the method once the system’s up and running. We can also equip the Nexis GC-2030 with two BID detectors to get more out of each analysis.
To find out more about BID: www.shimadzu.eu/gc/nexis_technologies/bid
What are the main applications for custom GC? The applications have changed a lot over the years. Initially, we were focused on analyzing refinery gases, and I think the first job we ever did was for liquified natural gas. In fact, that application became so popular that it stopped being a custom-built and became a prebuilt off-the-shelf product.
Now, about 80% of the systems we’re selling are for ‘new energy’ applications, with our primary customers being in academia. So, for example, we’re delivering systems to analyze methane and other gases generated from catalytic or light-mediated reduction of CO2 or for generating hydrogen from hydrocarbons for use in fuel cells. So, the thrust of the research is all about diversifying our energy sources and becoming less carbon-intensive in how we generate energy.
That’s obviously a hot topic at the moment given the current concerns about energy supply and sustainability. When did interest in using custom GC in this field get going? Here in the UK, it started about seven years ago with one or two groups – but it swiftly expanded to about 12 groups today. A main driver has been the generous funding available for this sort of research, which naturally has spurred a lot of groups to investigate it.
What’s interesting from the instrument point of view is the degree of ‘cross-pollination’ between researchers. So, one of the first academic groups who we sold a custom GC to was the Reisner group at Cambridge University, swiftly followed by University College London and Imperial College London. They produced papers citing the use of our GC with the BID detector, and then we found other groups got in touch wanting to set up a similar system for their work.
For details of these papers, get in touch with the team at Shimadzu by emailing email@example.com
What are the main challenges presented by such applications? A common theme through much of this research into ‘new energy’ is quantifying gases at a wide range of levels in one sample. So, for example, as well as bulk amounts of the gas you’re synthesizing, you may be looking for trace levels of impurities. Determining these values is vital for optimizing a process and making the end product as pure as possible – which is obviously vital if it’s going to be used on an industrial scale.
Another related application that has the same challenge is the analysis of greenhouse gases such as CO2, methane and nitrous oxide – again requiring determination of levels from low percent down to parts per billion, all in one analysis. Having the BID detector has really opened up these applications to us because it allows us to get down to the really low levels that researchers want.
Figure 4: Example of an analysis conducted using a custom GC system with three sample loops. For full details please see Application Data Sheet No. 126
How does this compare to other systems on the market? Well, it’s a different ball game, as they say. For example, many people are still using packed columns for gas analysis, which are fine for some purposes, but we’ve largely moved over to capillary columns now. The obvious benefits are better separation with faster runs, but they also work with smaller samples, which of course is perfect for lab-scale research. If customers have had previous experience with packed columns for gas analysis, then they’re usually pretty impressed by what can be achieved with capillary systems, especially in conjunction with the BID detector.
And in terms of the overall service that you offer, what makes customers come back to you? I think it’s really the bespoke service and the expertise we have – you don’t get that with every supplier. We’ve been doing custom GC at Shimadzu for nearly 20 years now, so we’ve accumulated a lot of knowledge about how to design systems for pretty much every situation, and customers really appreciate that. But there are always new challenges, and what’s great about many of our customers is that they’re always looking to push the boundaries of what’s possible, which keeps us on our toes!
Looking to the future, we’ve built up a great team here now, with a couple of specialists that I’ve trained up to know the ins and outs of the custom GC systems and the applications. Like me, they’re basically engineers with an analytical chemistry background, so they understand the customers’ requirements and design systems the best way and test them in our demo lab. And we pre-define the methods for our customers too, so once the system is installed and the customer has received training in the software, they can be up and running very quickly.
To wrap things up, what do you love most about working for Shimadzu? That’s a good question! I think it’s really the ability to help people and the satisfaction you get from successfully carrying out a challenging project. I’m a problem-solver at heart and I love getting stuck into a new challenge and seeing it through to completion.
For example, an application we worked on recently was particularly tricky because the customer wanted to detect low-ppm levels of permanent gases produced by a very small reaction cell. It took a while to design and optimize the system, but they’re very happy now. And that’s rewarding in itself, but of course it’s even better because we know we’re ultimately helping research into technologies that will provide a greener and more secure energy supply for future generations.
Thanks for your time, Pete, and for explaining your custom GC work – it’s been very interesting. No problem, it’s been a pleasure to talk to you!
Interested in speaking to the custom GC team about your application needs? Get in touch at firstname.lastname@example.org!
Peter Klawitter originally trained as an analytical chemist and then spent time in the pharmaceutical and service lab sectors following which he became a service engineer for Spectra Physics Analytical (later acquired by Thermo Electron). In 2003 he joined Shimadzu, initially working as an LC engineer, but soon focusing on designing and assembling their bespoke GC systems – a role he’s been in ever since.